Resources
Zimbabwe: multiple uses of water, gender roles and responsibilities, Chipinge (English)
This study from a village in the semi-arid south-east of Zimbabwe by Luckson Katsi from the University of Zimbabwe focuses on gender roles in the use of water.
Nepal: one development opportunity leads to another (English)
The broad benefits of an integrated water, sanitation and hygiene project which also included the promotion of kitchen gardening are described by Laba Hari Budhathoki of NEWAH in this case study from three villages in Nepal.
Jordan: greywater treatment and use for poverty reduction in Jordan (English)
This case study by Shihab Al-Beiruti of the The Inter-Islamic Network on Water Resources Development and Management (INWRDAM) presents research to treat wastewater at household level for reuse within gardens, contributing both to water savings and poverty reduction
Cape Verde: assessing the financial sustainability of water supply systems
In March 2005, IRC undertook a study to assess the financial sustainability of water supply systems for five municipal Autonomous Water and Sanitation Companies (SAAS) at the Santiago Island in Cape Verde. IRCs research in these areas led to the conclusion that, in some areas, due to the way in which tariffs are set, the productive use for irrigation from a multiple use water supply may lead to serious problems to equity and financial sustainability, thereby threatening and undermining the entire system.
India: rural water supply publication
A recent book from Unicef reflects upon some of the problems of a narrow focus on drinking water supply.
Presentation from MUS project
A powerpoint presented by Barbara van Koppen, IWMI, South Africa on multiple use of water systems(MUS).
Presentation from PLAN - East and Southern Africa
A powerpoint presented by Amsalu Negussi, Plan International, South Africa on effective water use for livelihood improvement in East and Southern Africa.
Presentation from India
A powerpoint presented by Joep Verhagen, IRC, Netherlands and Mihir Bhatt of the Disaster Mitigation Institute on multiple productive uses of water in small towns in India: the case of Bhuj.
Presentation from Colombia
A powerpoint presented by Ines Restrepo, Cinara, Colombia in june 2005 on multiple uses of water: three case studies in Valle del Cauca, Colombia.
South Africa: Water for productive livelihoods in South Africa's National Water Strategy
Echoing the earlier South African Department of Water Affairs and Forestry's recognition of the role of small-scale productive uses of water as an issue in water services delivery, the recent National Water Resources Stratgey specifically recognises this issue.
20. Water for livelihoods: bringing equity and opportunity to the rural poor in South Africa
A paper presented by Dirk Versfeld on 21-23 January 2003, Muldersdrift, South Africa.
South Africa is a water scarce country with a history reflected in deep inequities in the distribution of both land and water. The available water resource has for the most part been allocated to existing users - primarily agriculture, mining, industrial and urban. The country has a good record in providing basic minimum supplies of water to the rural poor and this effort is continuing. Only now is more thought being given to making larger volumes of water available for sustainable livelihoods, making this symposium on water for productive use particularly timely. The available runoff is now almost all utilised or captured and redistributed through dams and canals. There is little opportunity for further exploitation of the resource, and new users are now in competition for the existing available water. Irrigated agriculture is the key user, taking up 56% of the available resource with a contribution of only 4.7% to GDP. This makes it an obvious target for resource redistribution, yet the benefits are shown to be far wider than this primary contribution. It is ironic that the one way of easily redistributing water into the historically disadvantaged sector is through irrigated agriculture, yet this will only worsen the shortages experienced and will do little to resolve the fundamental issue – which is to make water 0really useful to a significantly large proportion of the rural poor. [authors abstract]
19. Poverty, water security and household use of water
A paper presented by John Soussan on 21-23 January 2003, Muldersdrift, South Africa.
This paper provides an overview of the key issues needed to understand the significance of water use within the household in relation to wider issues of water security and the reduction of poverty. It looks in
broad terms at the range of uses made of water within the household and relates this to the dynamics of the livelihoods of poor people from different segments of society and in different settings. It also sets out the wider context of household water use in relation to different aspects of access to and the availability of water resources. Finally, the paper considers how the issue of household water use relates to
overarching global and national development frameworks as expressed in the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) agreed at the UN Millennium Summit in 2000, the outcomes of the World Summit on Sustainable Development (WSSD) and national policies and development priorities such as the Poverty Reduction Strategy Papers (PRSPs). These issues are discussed in more detail below, but the overall message is that the concentration on consumption rather than productive uses of household water has meant that the development significance of household water use has been under-estimated. [authors abstract]
18. Changing the water paradigm for poverty reduction, Zimbabwe
A paper presented by Peter B. Robinson on 21-23 January 2003, Muldersdrift, South Africa.
At independence in 1980, the new government inherited a highly skewed economy with the majority of the population living on racially demarcated subsistence farming areas known as 'communal areas'. In rural water and sanitation programmes, the focus was on clean water for household use. It was anticipated that improved health would indirectly contribute to reduced poverty through higher levels of agricultural productivity. In fact, as a result of many factors, poverty in the communal areas increased markedly in both extent and depth, reaching alarming levels during the 1990s. The mainstream government water programmes have been based on community boreholes or deep wells. Although some are used to water vegetable gardens, there has never been more than a passing interest in providing water for productive uses. Instead, under the responsibility of a different ministry, the approach has been to build capital-intensive formal irrigation schemes, with water supplied from dams. By 1999 the total number of beneficiaries of these formal irrigation schemes were no more than 20,000 households, or 2% of the total number in the communal areas. [authors abstract]
17. Tackling the roots of poverty:Zimbabwe
A paper presented by David Proudfoot on 21-23 January 2003, Muldersdrift, South Africa.
This paper explains the changing nature of Zimbabwe’s approach to rural water supply over recent decades, and in particular the programme of a leading Zimbabwean water sector NGO, Mvuramanzi Trust. After summarising the changing approaches of the Trust, the paper reflects on the need for new approaches to respond the continuing need to improve water supplies and sanitation, and the changing nature of poverty in contemporary Zimbabwe. Case studies of attempts to respond to these new needs, especially the needs of a population severely affected by the impacts of high levels of HIV/AIDS, are considered. Crucially these include the needs of rural households to improve food security and engage in productive enterprise. Implications are drawn for non-governmental and governmental rural water supply and sanitation programmes in the country. [authors abstract]
16. Transforming village water access into profitable business opportunities
A paper presented by Paul Polak, Deepak Adhikari, Bob Nanes, Dan Salter and Sudarshan Surywanshi and Jack Keller on 21-23 January 2003, Muldersdrift, South Africa.
Although Colombia is rich in water resources, scarcity increasingly affects water supply in various regions of the country. This is mainly a scarcity of adequate water quality. This is also the situation in the
Department of the Valle del Cauca. The environmental authority of this Department (CVC) has contracted Cinara to contribute to resolving water use problems in a specific micro-catchment and at the
same time to develop methodologies that allow the replication of the work in other areas under jurisdiction of the CVC. The area selected for this project is the ‘Ambichinte’ micro-catchment located on the western slopes of the Andes, in the Municipality of Dagua. This paper presents both the methodology and results of the first phase; a participative appraisal of the water situation in the micro-catchment. The appraisal was done with the participation of both the community and institutions. It looked at the impact of water in all its aspects on the lives of people in the catchment, and drew out gender and poverty differences. Besides, the appraisal has tried to identify the demand and value people have for management and protection of the micro-watershed and for access to water for both domestic and productive uses. The demand was assessed by a Willingness To Pay (WTP) study in combination with the collection of other demand indicators. [authors abstract]
15. A participative appraisal of the water situation in a Colombian micro-catchment
A paper presented by Mario Pérez, Stef Smits, Alberto Benavides and Silena Vargas on 21-23 January 2003, Muldersdrift, South Africa.
Although Colombia is rich in water resources, scarcity increasingly affects water supply in various regions of the country. This is mainly a scarcity of adequate water quality. This is also the situation in the
Department of the Valle del Cauca. The environmental authority of this Department (CVC) has contracted Cinara to contribute to resolving water use problems in a specific micro-catchment and at the same time to develop methodologies that allow the replication of the work in other areas under jurisdiction of the CVC. The area selected for this project is the ‘Ambichinte’ micro-catchment located on the western slopes of the Andes, in the Municipality of Dagua. [authors abstract]
13. Chilwa catchment area in Southern Malawi
A paper presented by Wapulumuka O. Mulwafu on 21-23 January 2003, Muldersdrift, South Africa
Domestic water supplies are used not only for the traditional purposes of drinking, cooking and washing but they are also utilized for a variety of ‘non-domestic’ uses. In the Lake Chilwa Catchment area in southern Malawi, domestic water is increasingly being used for dry-season gardening, brick-making, livestock watering and small-scale business enterprises. These activities constitute an important element in the livelihoods of both rural and urban communities. Understanding the importance of multiple uses of water, in the lives of people in developing countries, has implications for how water supply systems are
developed and how water resources are managed. This paper reports on these issues from a wider research study on water resources management conducted, in southern Malawi. It is based on data collected through focus group discussions, key informant interviews, and field observations. [authors abstract]
12. The ownership and management of productive water point gardens in a time of drought, Zimbabwe
A paper presented by Brian Mathew on 21-23 January 2003, Muldersdrift, South Africa.
This paper presents practical experiences and new research into the provision and use of household water supplies from communal and family owned productive water point (PWP) gardens, in Bikita district,
Zimbabwe. Traditionally the people of the district are subsistence farmers who rely on rain fed agriculture and livestock. Where shallow ground water is available, households have dug wells to supply their domestic requirements, water cattle and other livestock, and to irrigate small family held garden plots. Recognising the importance of productive water, the DFID funded Bikita Integrated Rural Water Supply
and Sanitation Project and promoted PWP (PWP) gardens, as a pilot project to diversify livelihood strategies and move away from valuing water solely for domestic purposes. A high yielding water point is
considered productive when it has the capacity to deliver more water than is needed for the domestic uses of the community it serves. Thirty three communities, who were managing their high yielding water
points effectively and had suitable land available, were offered the opportunity to establish irrigated community gardens. The project also supported a significant number of households to upgrade their family wells, many of which were also used to water vegetable gardens. [authors abstract]
11. Evaluation of the water supply situation in the western Highveld area, South Africa
A paper presented by R.S. Mckenzie, H. Lombard, G. Constantinedes, N. Meyer and N. Adams on 21-23 January 2003, Muldersdrift, South Africa.
Participatory approaches to development are increasingly being advocated by development organizations and NGOs. However, putting these methods into practice is difficult, particularly where beneficiaries have
to contribute in kind and in cash. This presentation discusses the experiences, constraints and achievements in a participatory project, where beneficiaries were involved, in identification of problems, design of solutions and equity investment in the improvement of charco dams. A university research unit and an NGO were involved in providing technical backstopping with costs covered by a small grant from a regional programme. The project targeted agro-pastoralists who own private charco dams for harvesting and storing rainwater to supply water to livestock. However, although the group of agro-pastoralists was expected to be homogeneous, with common interests, it was very difficult to achieve common understanding. Had the charco dams been communally owned, it would have been difficult to implement the project. Only 50% of the targeted agro-pastoralists participated in the first year. However, nearly all have signed for the second year. It is important to identify their differences in objectives, interests and problems in-order to ensure a cross cutting participation in project planning, design and implementation. [authors abstract]
10. Challenges and benefits of participatory interventions in rainwater harvesting:Tanzania
A paper presented by H.F. Mahoo; F.B.R. Rwehumbiza; S. Demgard-Larsen; N. Hatibu; A. Kitali, and M. Kahabi on 21-23 January 2003, Muldersdrift, South Africa.
Participatory approaches to development are increasingly being advocated by development organizations and NGOs. However, putting these methods into practice is difficult, particularly where beneficiaries have
to contribute in kind and in cash. This presentation discusses the experiences, constraints and achievements in a participatory project, where beneficiaries were involved, in identification of problems, design of solutions and equity investment in the improvement of charco dams. A university research unit and an NGO were involved in providing technical backstopping with costs covered by a small grant from a regional programme. The project targeted agro-pastoralists who own private charco dams for harvesting and storing rainwater to supply water to livestock. However, although the group of agro-pastoralists was expected to be homogeneous, with common interests, it was very difficult to achieve common understanding. Had the charco dams been communally owned, it would have been difficult to implement the project. Only 50% of the targeted agro-pastoralists participated in the first year. However, nearly all have signed for the second year. It is important to identify their differences in objectives, interests and problems in-order to ensure a cross cutting participation in project planning, design and implementation. [authors abstract]
By the improvement of charco dams (Tanzania)
H.F. Mahoo; F.B.R. Rwehumbiza; S. Demgard-Larsen; N. Hatibu; A. Kitali, and M. Kahabi (2004)
09. Linking water supply and rural enterprise: issues and illustrations from India
A paper presented by A.J James on 21-23 January 2003, Muldersdrift, South Africa.
Improving domestic water supply has the potential to promote rural enterprise, reduce poverty and enhance rural livelihoods, but may not do so on its own. The term ‘rural enterprise’ refers here to household-based enterprise activity, like pottery, brick making, toddy tapping, salt-making, gum collection, livestock rearing, handicrafts, etc. While the link between water supply (irrigation) and agriculture is clear enough, the links between domestic water supply and rural enterprise are not always apparent. This paper explores two such links, using illustrations from rural India, before discussing the policy issue of
promoting rural enterprise and enhancing rural livelihoods through better domestic water supplies. The first link is that breakdowns in regular domestic water supply can impose (monetary and nonmonetary)
costs on those engaged in rural enterprise. Data from rural enterprises involving women in rural Gujarat are used to calculate the costs of temporary breakdowns in water supply. The second link is that improved domestic water supply can reduce household water collection time, and thus ‘create’ time that can be used for rural enterprise. This paper uses data from rural Gujarat to estimate the benefits of improved water supply, for the hypothetical case where it takes a household only one hour per day to collect domestic water. This case also illustrates how women augmenting household income through rural enterprise have a greater say in household decision-making over the use of their time and money. These links make a strong case for improving domestic water supply not only for the traditional reasons of reducing women’s drudgery and improving health and hygiene, but also to enhance household income, empower rural women, reduce poverty and thus improve rural livelihoods. [authors abstract]
08. The role of improved domestic water supply in livelihoods
A paper presented by Hope, P-J., Dixon, & G. von Maltitz on 21-23 January 2003, Muldersdrift, South Africa.
Managing water scarcity represents one of the key challenges in the trade-offs between economic growth, social justice and ecological integrity for developing countries. The poor are disproportionately affected by water scarcity due to their greater reliance on natural resources to generate sustainable livelihoods. Research in Limpopo Province, South Africa, is investigating the linkages between water and poverty. Domestic water supply was analysed as a potential intervention that achieves premised health benefits and a hidden leverage for productive benefits in food security for the poor. A catchment survey at the household level (n=552) is explored to unravel the linkages between domestic water provision and poverty. Findings are disaggregated according to three social cohort groups: Home husband, migrant husband and female-headed households, and by three mean household age profiles: 25-34, 35-44 and >45 years. All social cohorts undertake kitchen-garden farming as a significant livelihood activity. Over 70% of households consume all crops grown indicating the importance of this activity for food security. However, access to domestic water is disproportionately skewed in favour of the male-headed, income
wealthier households. The number of kitchen-garden crops grown is significantly associated with private water access. Willingness to pay for improved domestic water reflects current levels of delivery with older,
female-headed households reporting higher monetary values associated with lower levels of water access. The authors argue that improved domestic water access offers greater equity and food security
benefits to poorer households, but the efficiency and sustainability of such a poverty reduction intervention is questioned. [authors abstract]
07. Wastewater reuse for urban and periurban agriculture in Yaounde
A paper presented by D. Endamana, I.M. Kengne, J. Gockowski, J. Nya, D. Wandji, J. Nyemeck, N. N. Soua J. N. Bakwowi on 21-23 January 2003, Muldersdrift, South Africa.
Studies were conducted in three urban and two peri-urban sites in Yaounde to highlight the importance of food production in urban and peri-urban settings and the associated public health hazards. In each site, the physico-chemical, microbiological and parasitological properties of irrigation water were analysed and a socio-economic survey of urban and peri-urban agriculturalists conducted. The results show that water used for crop irrigation in the urban domain exceeds WHO bacterial and parasitic standards for unrestricted crop irrigation, in contrast to the peri-urban domain which met the standards. In the urban area, faecal coliforms and faecal streptococci are > 103 bacteria/100 ml and at least 33 % of the samples contained helminth eggs and cysts of protozoa. These wastewaters constitute therefore a potential source of health risk both for farmers of and consumers of the food produced in these milieus. Slightly less than half of the farmers interviewed attributed a health problem to their working environment. Among these farmers malaria, skin ulcers, bilharzia, typhoid fever and diarrhoea were the most frequently cited illnesses and the health expenses attributed to associate illness were estimated at approximately 62 Euros per year for each farmer. Furthermore, approximately 11 days of work are lost per year due to these illnesses. [authors abstract]
06. Innovation and infiltration: human ingenuity in the face of water shortage in India and Kenya
A paper presented by William Critchley and Marit Brommer on 21-23 January 2003, Muldersdrift, South Africa
In parts of both India and Kenya there are serious problems with shortage of water for domestic and agricultural purposes. In the Himalayan middle mountains of India, stripping of forest resources for livestock fodder impoverishes the forest floor. By changing the nature and composition of the forest, this impairs its hydrological function, and is a partial cause of the growing ‘low spring flow’ problem during the summer months. In semi-arid Mwingi District in eastern Kenya, surface runoff erodes land and constitutes waste of a precious resource. The vast majority there still depends, in the dry season, on digging for domestic water in sand rivers. Parallel participatory research in these contrasting areas has turned up similar principles – though rather different examples - of local innovation in the face of water shortage. The common denominator seems to be a search for a route out of poverty through prudent and judicious uses of limited water resources. These initiatives often involve the improvement of rainfall infiltration opportunities for productive purposes, and are typically located close to home. Four case studies are presented from each country. [authors abstract]
05. Productive uses of water at the household level: evidence from Bushbuckridge, South Africa
A paper presented by Juan Carlos Pérez de Mendiguren Castresana on 21-23 January 2003, Muldersdrift, South Africa
Demand Responsive Approach (DRA) was the “new phrase” in the South African Water Supply and Sanitation sector at the turn of the century. The fundamental basis of this new approach was that sustainable water systems at community level can only be achieved if people are provided with the level of service they want and are able to pay for. In other words, sustainability requires understanding and being responsive to people’s effective demand for water. Consequently, the obvious question to ask was how well do we understand that demand? The answer is not very well. Our current understanding of water demand for productive uses is biased towards formal sector users of water (Agriculture, Forestry, Mining, Industry and Tourism). Very little is known about water use and demand in rural communities and most of the research has focused on water for human consumption. Systems have been designed solely to provide small quantities of drinking quality water and, in many cases, the unit cost of the water is high.
But, do these systems meet demand for water in rural areas? Are there any “productive uses” for domestic water? How much water is demanded for these other uses? Is there an effective demand for this type of water (can people afford to pay for that water)? Are there any economic benefits to the use of this water? What happens when the system does not cater for this demand? Providing answers to this
type of questions is critical for practitioners, planners and policy makers in the Community Water and Sanitation sector. It will determine their ability to understand demand and therefore their ability to respond
to it. [authors abstract]